Table 1

Gene sets used for gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA)

Gene setNo. of genesDescription and sourceArray
GS1_TFH_up 57 Up-regulated in TFHs from Kim et al20  cDNA microarray 
GS2_TFH_up 100 Top 100 genes up-regulated in TFHs from Chtanova et al21  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS3_TFH_up 405 Up-regulated in TFHs from Chtanova et al21,22  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS4_TFH_up 443 GS1 plus GS3 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS5_TFH_up 16 Genes common to both GS1 and GS3 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS6_TFH_down 19 Down-regulated in TFHs from Kim et al20  cDNA microarray 
GS7_TFH_down 45 Down-regulated in TFHs from Chtanova et al21,22  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS8_TFH_down 63 GS6 plus GS7 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS9_Th1_up 138 Up-regulated in Th1 from Rogge et al19  HuGeneFL array, Affymetrix 
GS10_Th1_up 29 Up-regulated in Th1 from Chtanova et al21  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS11_Th1_up 159 GS9 plus GS10 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS12_Th2_up 50 Up-regulated in Th2 from Rogge et al19  HuGeneFL array, Affymetrix 
GS13_Th2_up 28 Up-regulated in Th2 from Chtanova et al21  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS14_Th2_up 73 GS12 plus GS13 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
Gene setNo. of genesDescription and sourceArray
GS1_TFH_up 57 Up-regulated in TFHs from Kim et al20  cDNA microarray 
GS2_TFH_up 100 Top 100 genes up-regulated in TFHs from Chtanova et al21  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS3_TFH_up 405 Up-regulated in TFHs from Chtanova et al21,22  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS4_TFH_up 443 GS1 plus GS3 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS5_TFH_up 16 Genes common to both GS1 and GS3 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS6_TFH_down 19 Down-regulated in TFHs from Kim et al20  cDNA microarray 
GS7_TFH_down 45 Down-regulated in TFHs from Chtanova et al21,22  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS8_TFH_down 63 GS6 plus GS7 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS9_Th1_up 138 Up-regulated in Th1 from Rogge et al19  HuGeneFL array, Affymetrix 
GS10_Th1_up 29 Up-regulated in Th1 from Chtanova et al21  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS11_Th1_up 159 GS9 plus GS10 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 
GS12_Th2_up 50 Up-regulated in Th2 from Rogge et al19  HuGeneFL array, Affymetrix 
GS13_Th2_up 28 Up-regulated in Th2 from Chtanova et al21  U133A and B Affymetrix 
GS14_Th2_up 73 GS12 plus GS13 cDNA microarray and Affymetrix 

Gene sets GS1 to GS14 are extracted from publications reporting gene expression signatures associated with purified subsets of CD4+ T cells.20–22  TFHs are defined as CD4+CD57+CXCR5+ cells isolated from tonsils,20–22  and Th1 and Th2 cells were obtained from cord blood cells cultured in appropriate polarizing conditions.19,21  The 97 transcripts (GenBank accession numbers) found by Kim et al20  to be differentially expressed in TFHs (CD4+CXCR5+CD57+) versus other CD4+ T-cell subsets (naive CD4+CD45RA+, early memory CD4+CXCR5+CCR7+), and effector memory CD4+CCR7) were mapped to 76 unique gene symbols represented on the Affymetrix U133plus2 GeneChip (57 overexpressed genes [GS1] and 19 down-regulated genes [GS6]). We used available gene symbols and/or accession numbers provided by Chtanova et al21,22  to map the described genes to the U133plus2.0 GeneChip. GS2 represents the top 100 genes overexpressed in TFHs according to Chtanova et al.21  The ranking of these genes was as follows: summing the individual fold change values between TFHs and the other T-cell samples (the maximum fold change was used for redundant data); ordering the sums from highest to lowest fold change; and selecting the top 100 genes as the first 100 genes in this ordered gene list. GS3 and GS7 correspond to the complete list of overexpressed and underexpressed genes in TFHs compared to other CD4+ T-cell subsets,21,22  respectively. The union of GS1 (n = 55) and GS3 (n = 405) yielded 443 overexpressed genes (GS4) in TFHs. The intersection of GS1 (n = 55) and GS3 (n = 405) yielded 16 common overexpressed genes in TFHs (GS5). The union of GS6 (n = 19) and GS7 (n = 45) yielded 63 underexpressed genes (GS8) in TFHs. In both studies by Rogge et al19  and Chtanova et al,21  the gene expression signature of the Th1 and Th2 subsets was defined by comapping each subset to the other one. Probe set identifiers provided by Rogge et al19  in the Table S1 were mapped to Entrez Gene identifiers using annotations provided by Affymetrix (NETAFFYX: http://www.affymetrix.com/analysis/index.affx), which were then used to map to U133plus2.0 probe sets yielding 138 genes (GS9) specifically overexpressed in Th1 cells and 50 genes (GS12) specifically overexpressed in Th2 cells. The genes specific to Th1 and Th2 described by Chtanova et al21  were mapped to the U133plus2.0 GeneChip, yielding, respectively, GS10 (29 genes) and GS13 (28 genes). The union of GS9 (n = 138) and GS10 (n = 29) yielded 159 overexpressed genes (GS11) in Th1 cells. The union of GS12 (n = 50) and GS13 (n = 28) yielded 73 overexpressed genes (GS14) in Th2 cells.

Close Modal

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal