Clinical studies evaluating hydroxyurea therapy in patients with β-thalassemia
Reference . | Sample . | Age (y)* . | HU dose (mg/kg per d)* . | Duration (mo) . | Total Hb (g/L)* . | Fetal Hb* . | Comments . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Karimi et al65 | 126 TM | 22.3 | 10 | 96-156 | Baseline: 85-100 | — | TI: NTD or TD [intermittent] |
Final: ≥90 (n = 51 [40%]) | TM: 86 [68.3%] TD → NTD, 25 [19.8%] TD → 1 or 2 transfusions | ||||||
Final: ≥80 to <90 (n = 44 [35%]) | |||||||
Final: ≥70 to <80 (n = 16 [13%]) | |||||||
Final: <70 (n = 15 [12%]) | |||||||
106 TI | 18.1 | 10 | 96-156 | Δ: +≥20 (n = 12 [11%]) | — | ||
Δ: +10 to <20 (n = 44 [42%]) | |||||||
Δ: +<10 (n = 47 [44%]) | |||||||
Δ: no change (n = 3 [3%]) | |||||||
Amoozgar et al66 | 33 TI | 20 | 10 | 12 | Baseline: 98.4 | Baseline: 79.3 g/L | TI: NTD or TD [intermittent] |
Δ: +13.4† | Δ: +8.0 g/L‡ | ||||||
51 TI | 17 | None | 12 | Baseline: 92.8 | — | ||
Δ: +4.7‡ | |||||||
Ansari et al67 | 119 TM | 2.6-25 | 16 | 24 | -Baseline: 75 | Baseline: 11.2% | TI: NTD |
Δ: +1‡ (responders, n = 33 [27.7%]) | Δ: +88.4% (responders) | Responders: TD → NTD | |||||
-Baseline: 82 | Partial responders: >50% ↓ in transfusion need | ||||||
Δ: −14† (partial responders, n = 57 [47.9%]) | |||||||
-Baseline: 79 | Nonresponders: <50% ↓ in transfusion need | ||||||
Δ: −13† (nonresponders, n = 29 [24.4%]) | |||||||
27 TI | 3-13 | 16 | 24 | Baseline: 67 | Baseline: 98.5% | ||
Δ: +11† | Δ: +1.4% | ||||||
Italia et al68 | 13 Hb E/β-thalassemia | 8-34 | 15-20 | 17-23 | -Baseline: 61 | -Baseline: 22.3% | Responders: TD → NTD |
(median 20) | Δ: +11† (responders, n = 6 [46.2%]) | Δ: +16%† (responders) | Partial responders: ↓ in transfusion need (30% to 50%) | ||||
-Baseline: 63 | F cells: +25.8%† | ||||||
Δ: 0‡ (partial responders, n = 4 [30.8%]) | -Baseline: 15.2% | Nonresponders: no change in transfusion need | |||||
-Baseline: 76 | Δ: +16.6%‡ (partial responders) | ||||||
Δ: −12‡ (nonresponders, n = 3 [23.1%]) | F cells: +18.5%‡ | ||||||
-Baseline: 2.9% | |||||||
Δ: +5.8%† (nonresponders) | |||||||
F cells: +13.3%† | |||||||
Karimi et al69 | 143 TI | 21 | 10.7 | 18-120 | Baseline: 74 | — | TI: NTD or TD |
(median 68.4) | Δ: +23† | ||||||
Rigano et al50 | 24 TI | 37 | 14.6 | 12 | Baseline: 78 | Baseline: 46.5% | TI: NTD |
Δ: +15† | Δ: +10.7%† | 17 patients with ΔHb > 10 g/L followed for >12 mo (mean: 68 mo); 9 maintained response, while 8 had reduction | |||||
Ehsani et al70 | 16 TI | 10.7 | 20 | 6 | Δ: +16 | Δ: +17 g/L | TI: NTD |
Italia et al44 | 41 TM | 12-28 | 15-20 | 20-24 | -Baseline: 81 | -Baseline: 5.4% | TI: TD [intermittent] or TD |
Δ: −5‡ (partial responders, n = 13 [31.7%]) | Δ: +32%† (partial responders) | Responders: TD → NTD | |||||
-Baseline: 76 | F cells: +40.9%† | Partial responders: >50% ↓ in transfusion need | |||||
Δ: −5‡ (nonresponders, n = 28 [68.3%]) | -Baseline: 3.7% | ||||||
Δ: +8.2%† (nonresponders) | Dose increases to 30 mg/kg per day in nonresponders had no benefit | ||||||
F cells: +13.8%† | |||||||
38 TI | 5-40 | 15-20 | 20-24 | -Baseline: 76 | -Baseline: 51.8% | ||
Δ: +15† (responders, n = 22 [57.9%]) | Δ: +35.4%† (responders) | ||||||
-Baseline: 79 | F cells: +27.4%† | ||||||
Δ: −2‡ (partial responders, n = 6 [15.8%]) | -Baseline: 6.3% | ||||||
-Baseline: 63 | Δ: +31.1%† (partial responders) | ||||||
Δ: −2‡ (nonresponders, n = 10 [26.3%]) | F cells: +33.3%† | ||||||
-Baseline: 25.9% | |||||||
Δ: +20%† (nonresponders) | |||||||
F cells: +32.8%† | |||||||
Zamani et al71 | 49 TM | 18.4 | 10 | 12 | Baseline: 85.2 | — | Mean number of transfused units ↓ from 22.8 → 6.0† |
Δ: −0.7† | |||||||
12 [24.5%] became NTD | |||||||
Koren et al72 | 11 TM | 18 | 10.9 | 5-60 | Responders, n = 9 [81.8%] | Baseline: 83% | TI: NTD or TD [intermittent] |
(median 24) | Δ: −1% (1 y) ‡, −5% (2 y) ‡ | Responders: TD → NTD (maintaining an Hb of 70 g/L in TM and 60 g/L in TI) | |||||
7 TI | 18 | 10.9 | 36-96 | -Baseline: 67 | Baseline: 15% | ||
(median 60) | Δ: +2 (5 TD, responders, n = 5 [100%]) | Δ: +13%‡ (1 y), +8% (2 y) ‡ | |||||
-Baseline: 66 | |||||||
Δ: +18 (2 NTD) | |||||||
Mtvarelidze et al73 | 6 TM | 9.8 | 15 | 60 | Baseline: 94 | Baseline: 23% | 3 [50%] patients: TD → NTD |
Δ: +1 (12 mo), +3 (60 mo) | Δ: +8.3% (12 mo), +20.4 (60 mo) | 2 [33.3%] patients: ↓ in transfusion need after 1 y | |||||
Ansari et al74 | 23 TM | 8.7 | 16 | 24 | Baseline: 86 | — | 42.8% ↓ in blood volume transfused |
Δ: −14 | 68.7% ↑ in transfusion interval | ||||||
Bradai et al75 | 45 TM | 10 | 17.4 | 12 | Δ: +15 (good responders, n = 20 [44.4%]) | — | TI: TD |
Δ: +7 (partial responders, n = 9 [20%]) | Good responders: >70% ↓ in transfusion need | ||||||
Δ: +2 (nonresponders, n = 16 [35.6%]) | |||||||
Partial responders: 40% to 70% ↓ in transfusion need | |||||||
9 TI | 12.5 | 17 | 12 | Δ: +37 (8 good responders [88.9%], 1 nonresponder [11.1%]) | — | Nonresponders: <40% ↓ in transfusion need | |
Mancuso et al76 | 18 TI | 37 | 14.6 | 12 | Δ: +15† | — | TI: NTD |
11 patients with ΔHb > 10 g/L were followed for >12 mo (mean: 66 mo); 7 maintained response, while 4 had reduction | |||||||
Taher and Sheikh-Taha84 | 7 TI | 24 | 10-20 | 6-46 | Baseline: 70 | — | TI: NTD |
(median 12) | Δ: +5 | ||||||
Singer et al85 | 45 Hb E/β-thalassemia | 13 | 18-20 | 24 | Baseline: 68 | Baseline: 29.8% | Patients weaned off transfusions before study |
Δ: +6 | Δ: +6.7% | ||||||
16 [38%] patients had ΔHb > 10 g/L | |||||||
Dixit et al77 | 37 TM + TI | 10 | 10->20 | 6 | -Baseline: 65 | -Baseline: 67% | -TI: NTD, TD [intermittent], or TD |
Δ: +26† (major responders, n = 17 [45.9%]) | Δ: +9%† (major responders) | Major responders: TD → NTD (Hb > 80 g/L), or Hb ↑ >20 g/L | |||||
-Baseline: 63 | -Baseline: 70.2% | ||||||
Δ: +18† (minor responders, n = 9 [24.3%]) | Δ: +8.5‡ (minor responders) | Minor responders: TD → NTD (Hb < 80 g/L), >50% ↓ in transfusion need, or Hb ↑ 10 to 20 g/L | |||||
-Baseline: 65 | -Baseline: 40.9% | ||||||
Δ: +5† (nonresponders, n = 11 [29.7%]) | Δ: +1%‡ (nonresponders) | ||||||
Nonresponders: <50% ↓ in transfusion need, or Hb ↑ <10 g/L | |||||||
Karimi et al78 | 163 TI | 13.5 | 10 | 72 | Baseline: 86.8 | Nonsignificant changes | TI: group 1 (n = 120) TD, group 2 (n = 16) TD [intermittent], and group 3 (n = 27) NTD |
Δ: +9.6† (group 2 + 3, 12 mo) | |||||||
Group 1: 83 [69.2%] TD → NTD, 23 [19.2%] TD → 1 or 2 transfusions | |||||||
Group 2: 14 [87.5%] TD → NTD | |||||||
Alebouyeh et al79 | 36 TM | 16.3 | 20 | >6 | Baseline: 100 | — | TI: NTD |
Δ: +7 | 25 [69.4%] TM patients TD → NTD | ||||||
9 TI | 14.7 | 20 | 34-58 | Baseline: 93 | — | ||
(median 40) | Δ: +11 | ||||||
Yavarian et al80 | 133 TM | 17.1 | 10-15 | 24-60 | Good responders: n = 81 [60.9%] | — | Good responders: TD → NTD (Hb > 95 g/L) |
(median 42) | Moderate responders: n = 31 [23.3%] | ||||||
Moderate responders: transfusion interval >6 mo (Hb 75 to 96 g/L) | |||||||
Nonresponders: TD after 12 mo | |||||||
Bradai et al81 | 7 TM + TI | 12 | 18.4 | 13-21 | -Baseline: 45 | Baseline: 90.9% | TI: TD |
(median 19) | Δ: +34 (TM) | Δ: +6.8% | 5 [71.4%] patients: TD → NTD | ||||
-Baseline: 65 | 2 [28.6%] TD → 1 or 2 transfusions | ||||||
Δ: +40 (TI) | |||||||
de Paula et al82 | 4 TM | 18 | 10->20 | 6-96 | Δ: +30 in 1 patient after 3 mo, no change in 3 patients | — | TI: TD [intermittent] |
1 TM patient became NTD after 3 mo | |||||||
7 TI | 35 | 10->20 | 6 | Baseline: 77 | Baseline: 44.9% | ΔHb > 10 g/L noted in 3 TI patients at 6 mo, 1 patient showed further response at 12 mo, no additional responses noted after >12 mo | |
Δ: +10† | Δ: +12.3%† | ||||||
Choudhry et al83 | 15 TM | 3-6 | 50 | 3 5-d courses | Δ: +8‡ | 2-fold rise in 8 [53.3%] patients | Response continued for 6 mo in 9 [60%] patients |
Fucharoen et al49 | 13 Hb E/β-thalassemia | 34 | 15 | 5 | Baseline: 65 | Baseline: 42% | — |
Δ: +7.4† | Δ: +32.5%† | ||||||
F cells: ↑ by 1/3 |
Reference . | Sample . | Age (y)* . | HU dose (mg/kg per d)* . | Duration (mo) . | Total Hb (g/L)* . | Fetal Hb* . | Comments . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Karimi et al65 | 126 TM | 22.3 | 10 | 96-156 | Baseline: 85-100 | — | TI: NTD or TD [intermittent] |
Final: ≥90 (n = 51 [40%]) | TM: 86 [68.3%] TD → NTD, 25 [19.8%] TD → 1 or 2 transfusions | ||||||
Final: ≥80 to <90 (n = 44 [35%]) | |||||||
Final: ≥70 to <80 (n = 16 [13%]) | |||||||
Final: <70 (n = 15 [12%]) | |||||||
106 TI | 18.1 | 10 | 96-156 | Δ: +≥20 (n = 12 [11%]) | — | ||
Δ: +10 to <20 (n = 44 [42%]) | |||||||
Δ: +<10 (n = 47 [44%]) | |||||||
Δ: no change (n = 3 [3%]) | |||||||
Amoozgar et al66 | 33 TI | 20 | 10 | 12 | Baseline: 98.4 | Baseline: 79.3 g/L | TI: NTD or TD [intermittent] |
Δ: +13.4† | Δ: +8.0 g/L‡ | ||||||
51 TI | 17 | None | 12 | Baseline: 92.8 | — | ||
Δ: +4.7‡ | |||||||
Ansari et al67 | 119 TM | 2.6-25 | 16 | 24 | -Baseline: 75 | Baseline: 11.2% | TI: NTD |
Δ: +1‡ (responders, n = 33 [27.7%]) | Δ: +88.4% (responders) | Responders: TD → NTD | |||||
-Baseline: 82 | Partial responders: >50% ↓ in transfusion need | ||||||
Δ: −14† (partial responders, n = 57 [47.9%]) | |||||||
-Baseline: 79 | Nonresponders: <50% ↓ in transfusion need | ||||||
Δ: −13† (nonresponders, n = 29 [24.4%]) | |||||||
27 TI | 3-13 | 16 | 24 | Baseline: 67 | Baseline: 98.5% | ||
Δ: +11† | Δ: +1.4% | ||||||
Italia et al68 | 13 Hb E/β-thalassemia | 8-34 | 15-20 | 17-23 | -Baseline: 61 | -Baseline: 22.3% | Responders: TD → NTD |
(median 20) | Δ: +11† (responders, n = 6 [46.2%]) | Δ: +16%† (responders) | Partial responders: ↓ in transfusion need (30% to 50%) | ||||
-Baseline: 63 | F cells: +25.8%† | ||||||
Δ: 0‡ (partial responders, n = 4 [30.8%]) | -Baseline: 15.2% | Nonresponders: no change in transfusion need | |||||
-Baseline: 76 | Δ: +16.6%‡ (partial responders) | ||||||
Δ: −12‡ (nonresponders, n = 3 [23.1%]) | F cells: +18.5%‡ | ||||||
-Baseline: 2.9% | |||||||
Δ: +5.8%† (nonresponders) | |||||||
F cells: +13.3%† | |||||||
Karimi et al69 | 143 TI | 21 | 10.7 | 18-120 | Baseline: 74 | — | TI: NTD or TD |
(median 68.4) | Δ: +23† | ||||||
Rigano et al50 | 24 TI | 37 | 14.6 | 12 | Baseline: 78 | Baseline: 46.5% | TI: NTD |
Δ: +15† | Δ: +10.7%† | 17 patients with ΔHb > 10 g/L followed for >12 mo (mean: 68 mo); 9 maintained response, while 8 had reduction | |||||
Ehsani et al70 | 16 TI | 10.7 | 20 | 6 | Δ: +16 | Δ: +17 g/L | TI: NTD |
Italia et al44 | 41 TM | 12-28 | 15-20 | 20-24 | -Baseline: 81 | -Baseline: 5.4% | TI: TD [intermittent] or TD |
Δ: −5‡ (partial responders, n = 13 [31.7%]) | Δ: +32%† (partial responders) | Responders: TD → NTD | |||||
-Baseline: 76 | F cells: +40.9%† | Partial responders: >50% ↓ in transfusion need | |||||
Δ: −5‡ (nonresponders, n = 28 [68.3%]) | -Baseline: 3.7% | ||||||
Δ: +8.2%† (nonresponders) | Dose increases to 30 mg/kg per day in nonresponders had no benefit | ||||||
F cells: +13.8%† | |||||||
38 TI | 5-40 | 15-20 | 20-24 | -Baseline: 76 | -Baseline: 51.8% | ||
Δ: +15† (responders, n = 22 [57.9%]) | Δ: +35.4%† (responders) | ||||||
-Baseline: 79 | F cells: +27.4%† | ||||||
Δ: −2‡ (partial responders, n = 6 [15.8%]) | -Baseline: 6.3% | ||||||
-Baseline: 63 | Δ: +31.1%† (partial responders) | ||||||
Δ: −2‡ (nonresponders, n = 10 [26.3%]) | F cells: +33.3%† | ||||||
-Baseline: 25.9% | |||||||
Δ: +20%† (nonresponders) | |||||||
F cells: +32.8%† | |||||||
Zamani et al71 | 49 TM | 18.4 | 10 | 12 | Baseline: 85.2 | — | Mean number of transfused units ↓ from 22.8 → 6.0† |
Δ: −0.7† | |||||||
12 [24.5%] became NTD | |||||||
Koren et al72 | 11 TM | 18 | 10.9 | 5-60 | Responders, n = 9 [81.8%] | Baseline: 83% | TI: NTD or TD [intermittent] |
(median 24) | Δ: −1% (1 y) ‡, −5% (2 y) ‡ | Responders: TD → NTD (maintaining an Hb of 70 g/L in TM and 60 g/L in TI) | |||||
7 TI | 18 | 10.9 | 36-96 | -Baseline: 67 | Baseline: 15% | ||
(median 60) | Δ: +2 (5 TD, responders, n = 5 [100%]) | Δ: +13%‡ (1 y), +8% (2 y) ‡ | |||||
-Baseline: 66 | |||||||
Δ: +18 (2 NTD) | |||||||
Mtvarelidze et al73 | 6 TM | 9.8 | 15 | 60 | Baseline: 94 | Baseline: 23% | 3 [50%] patients: TD → NTD |
Δ: +1 (12 mo), +3 (60 mo) | Δ: +8.3% (12 mo), +20.4 (60 mo) | 2 [33.3%] patients: ↓ in transfusion need after 1 y | |||||
Ansari et al74 | 23 TM | 8.7 | 16 | 24 | Baseline: 86 | — | 42.8% ↓ in blood volume transfused |
Δ: −14 | 68.7% ↑ in transfusion interval | ||||||
Bradai et al75 | 45 TM | 10 | 17.4 | 12 | Δ: +15 (good responders, n = 20 [44.4%]) | — | TI: TD |
Δ: +7 (partial responders, n = 9 [20%]) | Good responders: >70% ↓ in transfusion need | ||||||
Δ: +2 (nonresponders, n = 16 [35.6%]) | |||||||
Partial responders: 40% to 70% ↓ in transfusion need | |||||||
9 TI | 12.5 | 17 | 12 | Δ: +37 (8 good responders [88.9%], 1 nonresponder [11.1%]) | — | Nonresponders: <40% ↓ in transfusion need | |
Mancuso et al76 | 18 TI | 37 | 14.6 | 12 | Δ: +15† | — | TI: NTD |
11 patients with ΔHb > 10 g/L were followed for >12 mo (mean: 66 mo); 7 maintained response, while 4 had reduction | |||||||
Taher and Sheikh-Taha84 | 7 TI | 24 | 10-20 | 6-46 | Baseline: 70 | — | TI: NTD |
(median 12) | Δ: +5 | ||||||
Singer et al85 | 45 Hb E/β-thalassemia | 13 | 18-20 | 24 | Baseline: 68 | Baseline: 29.8% | Patients weaned off transfusions before study |
Δ: +6 | Δ: +6.7% | ||||||
16 [38%] patients had ΔHb > 10 g/L | |||||||
Dixit et al77 | 37 TM + TI | 10 | 10->20 | 6 | -Baseline: 65 | -Baseline: 67% | -TI: NTD, TD [intermittent], or TD |
Δ: +26† (major responders, n = 17 [45.9%]) | Δ: +9%† (major responders) | Major responders: TD → NTD (Hb > 80 g/L), or Hb ↑ >20 g/L | |||||
-Baseline: 63 | -Baseline: 70.2% | ||||||
Δ: +18† (minor responders, n = 9 [24.3%]) | Δ: +8.5‡ (minor responders) | Minor responders: TD → NTD (Hb < 80 g/L), >50% ↓ in transfusion need, or Hb ↑ 10 to 20 g/L | |||||
-Baseline: 65 | -Baseline: 40.9% | ||||||
Δ: +5† (nonresponders, n = 11 [29.7%]) | Δ: +1%‡ (nonresponders) | ||||||
Nonresponders: <50% ↓ in transfusion need, or Hb ↑ <10 g/L | |||||||
Karimi et al78 | 163 TI | 13.5 | 10 | 72 | Baseline: 86.8 | Nonsignificant changes | TI: group 1 (n = 120) TD, group 2 (n = 16) TD [intermittent], and group 3 (n = 27) NTD |
Δ: +9.6† (group 2 + 3, 12 mo) | |||||||
Group 1: 83 [69.2%] TD → NTD, 23 [19.2%] TD → 1 or 2 transfusions | |||||||
Group 2: 14 [87.5%] TD → NTD | |||||||
Alebouyeh et al79 | 36 TM | 16.3 | 20 | >6 | Baseline: 100 | — | TI: NTD |
Δ: +7 | 25 [69.4%] TM patients TD → NTD | ||||||
9 TI | 14.7 | 20 | 34-58 | Baseline: 93 | — | ||
(median 40) | Δ: +11 | ||||||
Yavarian et al80 | 133 TM | 17.1 | 10-15 | 24-60 | Good responders: n = 81 [60.9%] | — | Good responders: TD → NTD (Hb > 95 g/L) |
(median 42) | Moderate responders: n = 31 [23.3%] | ||||||
Moderate responders: transfusion interval >6 mo (Hb 75 to 96 g/L) | |||||||
Nonresponders: TD after 12 mo | |||||||
Bradai et al81 | 7 TM + TI | 12 | 18.4 | 13-21 | -Baseline: 45 | Baseline: 90.9% | TI: TD |
(median 19) | Δ: +34 (TM) | Δ: +6.8% | 5 [71.4%] patients: TD → NTD | ||||
-Baseline: 65 | 2 [28.6%] TD → 1 or 2 transfusions | ||||||
Δ: +40 (TI) | |||||||
de Paula et al82 | 4 TM | 18 | 10->20 | 6-96 | Δ: +30 in 1 patient after 3 mo, no change in 3 patients | — | TI: TD [intermittent] |
1 TM patient became NTD after 3 mo | |||||||
7 TI | 35 | 10->20 | 6 | Baseline: 77 | Baseline: 44.9% | ΔHb > 10 g/L noted in 3 TI patients at 6 mo, 1 patient showed further response at 12 mo, no additional responses noted after >12 mo | |
Δ: +10† | Δ: +12.3%† | ||||||
Choudhry et al83 | 15 TM | 3-6 | 50 | 3 5-d courses | Δ: +8‡ | 2-fold rise in 8 [53.3%] patients | Response continued for 6 mo in 9 [60%] patients |
Fucharoen et al49 | 13 Hb E/β-thalassemia | 34 | 15 | 5 | Baseline: 65 | Baseline: 42% | — |
Δ: +7.4† | Δ: +32.5%† | ||||||
F cells: ↑ by 1/3 |
Hb, hemoglobin; HU, hydroxyurea; NTD, nontransfusion dependent; TD, transfusion dependent; TI, β-thalassemia intermedia; TM, β-thalassemia major.
All values represent the central tendency (mean or median) unless otherwise indicated. For HU dose, the fixed or actual mean/median maximal tolerated dose is indicated when reported; otherwise, the dosing scheme is described.
Statistically significant (P < .05).
Statistically insignificant (P > .05).