Table 3.

Summary of study findings

Study (year)Main results
Hair cortisol 
Hollister et al28 (2021) Disease severity
  • Hair cortisol content was not associated with a cumulative disease severity index.

Hematological measures
  • Hair cortisol was positively related to eosinophil levels.

  • Hair cortisol was negatively related to HbS.

  • Hair cortisol content was not associated with Hb level, white blood cell count, mean corpuscular volume, differential lymphocytes, differential monocytes, platelets, reticulocytes, blood urea nitrogen, creatinine, uric acid, total bilirubin, aspartate aminotransferase, alkaline phosphatase, albumin, or fetal Hb.

Serum hormones
  • Hair cortisol was positively associated with serum cortisol, corticosterone, and progesterone.

 
Saliva cortisol 
Kölbel et al29 (2022) Comparison with control group (combined HbAS and HbAA)
  • Morning saliva cortisol and diurnal cortisol ratio were not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

  • Cortisol profiles

  • Participants with SCD displayed either normal cortisol profiles (n = 8) or flat cortisol profiles (n = 13).

  • Morning saliva cortisol was lower in participants with flat cortisol profile relative to participants with a normal cortisol profile.

  • Diurnal saliva cortisol was higher in participants with flat cortisol profile relative to participants with a normal cortisol profile.

Sleep profiles
  • Morning saliva cortisol was negatively correlated with wake time for participants with SCD.

  • Participants with a flat saliva cortisol profile had a later wake time and higher central phase relative to participants with a normal cortisol profile.

  • Comparisons across cortisol profiles were not statistically significant for total sleep time, bedtime, sleep onset latency, night waking, wake bouts mobile minutes, or fragmentation index.

Cognitive profiles
  • Comparisons across cortisol profiles were not statistically significant for full scale IQ, verbal comprehension index, perceptual reasoning index, working memory index, and processing speed index; however, each index was lower in participants with a flat cortisol level (not statistically significant).

 
Serum cortisol 
Akinlade et al30 (2013)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Serum cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD (total sample and steady state) relative to the control group.

  • Serum cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC relative to the control group.

VOC
  • Serum cortisol was significantly higher in participants with SCD during VOC relative to participants with SCD in steady state.

  • Serum cortisol in participants with SCD during VOC was not associated with verbal pain scores upon admission or number of days spent in the hospital.

 
Akinlade et al31 (2013) Disease severity
  • Serum cortisol was significantly higher in participants with severe SCA compared with patients with mild SCA.

  • Cortisol-to-copeptin ratio was higher in subjects with severe SCA compared with those with moderate SCA.

  • Cortisol-to-CRP ratio was not significantly different across disease severity groups.

 
Bashir et al32 (1993)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower among patients with SCD relative to the control group.

 
El-Sonbaty et al33 (2016)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Hydroxyurea use
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD receiving hydroxyurea relative to participants with SCD not receiving hydroxyurea.

VOC frequency
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly related to VOC frequency during the year before blood draw.

Clinical and laboratory values
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly related to age, gender, melatonin level, weight, height, or body mass index.

 
Garadah et al34 (2016)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Serum cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • 4.8% of participants with SCD (4/82) displayed low cortisol (defined as morning cortisol of <190 nmol/L).

Ferritin
  • Serum cortisol was not associated with ferritin level.

 
Groom et al35 (1990) Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Of 9 participants with SCD, 1 (11%) displayed elevated serum cortisol level (defined as cortisol range of 44-1030 nmol/L).

 
Hagag et al36 (2015)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Morning serum cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • ACTH-stimulated cortisol level 60 minutes after stimulation was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Iron
  • Morning serum cortisol was inversely correlated with serum iron levels, and it was positively correlated with total iron binding capacity.

Ferritin
  • Morning serum cortisol was inversely correlated with ferritin level.

 
Soliman et al38 (1995)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • ACTH-stimulated cortisol level 60 minutes after stimulation was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

 
Soliman et al37 (1995)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • Peak ACTH-stimulated cortisol level was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group during the 180-minute test.

 
Solomon et al39 (2012) Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Of 38 participants with SCD, 24 (63%) displayed low serum cortisol (defined as <7 μg/dL) on at least 1 occasion.

  • When only morning cortisol values were considered (4 AM to 8 AM), 13 of 20 (65%) of participants with valid samples displayed low serum cortisol

ACTH stimulation
  • Of 16 participants with low cortisol (defined as <7 μg/dL on at least 1 occasion), 10 (63%) showed cosyntropin-stimulated cortisol increases to ≥18 μg/dL after 1 hour.

 
Plasma cortisol 
Adams et al40 (2017) Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Of 36 participants with SCD, 7 (20%) displayed suppressed plasma cortisol (defined as cortisol of <100 IU/L)

Opioid dose
  • Plasma cortisol was not correlated with opioid dose.

 
el-Hazmi et al41 (1992)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower among male and female participants with SCD relative to male and female controls, respectively.

Comparisons of males and females with SCD
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among male participants with SCD relative to female participants with SCD.

Disease severity
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different across disease severity groups (measured using a cumulative disease severity index) among male and female participants.

 
el-Hazmi et al42 (1994)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Gonadotropic hormones
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly correlated with luteinizing hormone, follicle stimulating, and testosterone.

 
Grewen et al43 (2012) Pain intensity
  • Plasma cortisol among participants with SCD was positively correlated with pain intensity (measured using the visual pain analog pain scale)

Oxytocin
  • Plasma cortisol was positively correlated with oxytocin.

 
Osifo et al44 (1988)  Comparison with control groups (separate HbAA and HbAS groups)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower in participants with SCD relative to healthy controls (HbAA).

  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different in participants with SCD relative to participants with sickle cell trait (HbAS).

Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower than the normal range (defined as 165-825 nmol/L) in 9 of 36 participants with SCD.

VOC
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly higher in participants with SCD during VOC relative to participants with SCD during routine clinic appointment.

 
Rosenbloom et al45 (1980) Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Baseline plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during steady state relative to the control group.

  • Baseline plasma cortisol was significantly lower in participants with SCD during VOC relative to the control group.

VOC
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC relative to repeated measures plasma cortisol among the same participants in steady state.

ACTH stimulation across VOC status
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC relative to participants with SCD in steady state 60 minutes after ACTH stimulation.

Insulin stimulation
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC and in steady state relative to the control group at 30 or 60 minutes after insulin stimulation.

  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower in participants with SCD during VOC relative to the control group at 90 minutes after insulin stimulation.

  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD without VOC relative to the control group at 90 minutes after insulin stimulation.

 
Saad and Saad46 (1992)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • ACTH-stimulated cortisol level was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group at 30, 60, and 120 minutes after stimulation.

 
Sobngwi et al47 (2018)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group 60 minutes after tetracosactide stimulation.

  • The change in plasma cortisol from baseline to after tetracosactide stimulation was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

  • Of 10 participants with SCD, 5 (50%) did not achieve “optimal adrenal stimulation” (defined as reaching a twofold increase of basal plasma cortisol) after tetracosactide stimulation.

 
Study (year)Main results
Hair cortisol 
Hollister et al28 (2021) Disease severity
  • Hair cortisol content was not associated with a cumulative disease severity index.

Hematological measures
  • Hair cortisol was positively related to eosinophil levels.

  • Hair cortisol was negatively related to HbS.

  • Hair cortisol content was not associated with Hb level, white blood cell count, mean corpuscular volume, differential lymphocytes, differential monocytes, platelets, reticulocytes, blood urea nitrogen, creatinine, uric acid, total bilirubin, aspartate aminotransferase, alkaline phosphatase, albumin, or fetal Hb.

Serum hormones
  • Hair cortisol was positively associated with serum cortisol, corticosterone, and progesterone.

 
Saliva cortisol 
Kölbel et al29 (2022) Comparison with control group (combined HbAS and HbAA)
  • Morning saliva cortisol and diurnal cortisol ratio were not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

  • Cortisol profiles

  • Participants with SCD displayed either normal cortisol profiles (n = 8) or flat cortisol profiles (n = 13).

  • Morning saliva cortisol was lower in participants with flat cortisol profile relative to participants with a normal cortisol profile.

  • Diurnal saliva cortisol was higher in participants with flat cortisol profile relative to participants with a normal cortisol profile.

Sleep profiles
  • Morning saliva cortisol was negatively correlated with wake time for participants with SCD.

  • Participants with a flat saliva cortisol profile had a later wake time and higher central phase relative to participants with a normal cortisol profile.

  • Comparisons across cortisol profiles were not statistically significant for total sleep time, bedtime, sleep onset latency, night waking, wake bouts mobile minutes, or fragmentation index.

Cognitive profiles
  • Comparisons across cortisol profiles were not statistically significant for full scale IQ, verbal comprehension index, perceptual reasoning index, working memory index, and processing speed index; however, each index was lower in participants with a flat cortisol level (not statistically significant).

 
Serum cortisol 
Akinlade et al30 (2013)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Serum cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD (total sample and steady state) relative to the control group.

  • Serum cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC relative to the control group.

VOC
  • Serum cortisol was significantly higher in participants with SCD during VOC relative to participants with SCD in steady state.

  • Serum cortisol in participants with SCD during VOC was not associated with verbal pain scores upon admission or number of days spent in the hospital.

 
Akinlade et al31 (2013) Disease severity
  • Serum cortisol was significantly higher in participants with severe SCA compared with patients with mild SCA.

  • Cortisol-to-copeptin ratio was higher in subjects with severe SCA compared with those with moderate SCA.

  • Cortisol-to-CRP ratio was not significantly different across disease severity groups.

 
Bashir et al32 (1993)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower among patients with SCD relative to the control group.

 
El-Sonbaty et al33 (2016)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Hydroxyurea use
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD receiving hydroxyurea relative to participants with SCD not receiving hydroxyurea.

VOC frequency
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly related to VOC frequency during the year before blood draw.

Clinical and laboratory values
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly related to age, gender, melatonin level, weight, height, or body mass index.

 
Garadah et al34 (2016)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Serum cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • 4.8% of participants with SCD (4/82) displayed low cortisol (defined as morning cortisol of <190 nmol/L).

Ferritin
  • Serum cortisol was not associated with ferritin level.

 
Groom et al35 (1990) Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Of 9 participants with SCD, 1 (11%) displayed elevated serum cortisol level (defined as cortisol range of 44-1030 nmol/L).

 
Hagag et al36 (2015)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Morning serum cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • ACTH-stimulated cortisol level 60 minutes after stimulation was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Iron
  • Morning serum cortisol was inversely correlated with serum iron levels, and it was positively correlated with total iron binding capacity.

Ferritin
  • Morning serum cortisol was inversely correlated with ferritin level.

 
Soliman et al38 (1995)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • ACTH-stimulated cortisol level 60 minutes after stimulation was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

 
Soliman et al37 (1995)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • Peak ACTH-stimulated cortisol level was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group during the 180-minute test.

 
Solomon et al39 (2012) Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Of 38 participants with SCD, 24 (63%) displayed low serum cortisol (defined as <7 μg/dL) on at least 1 occasion.

  • When only morning cortisol values were considered (4 AM to 8 AM), 13 of 20 (65%) of participants with valid samples displayed low serum cortisol

ACTH stimulation
  • Of 16 participants with low cortisol (defined as <7 μg/dL on at least 1 occasion), 10 (63%) showed cosyntropin-stimulated cortisol increases to ≥18 μg/dL after 1 hour.

 
Plasma cortisol 
Adams et al40 (2017) Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Of 36 participants with SCD, 7 (20%) displayed suppressed plasma cortisol (defined as cortisol of <100 IU/L)

Opioid dose
  • Plasma cortisol was not correlated with opioid dose.

 
el-Hazmi et al41 (1992)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower among male and female participants with SCD relative to male and female controls, respectively.

Comparisons of males and females with SCD
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among male participants with SCD relative to female participants with SCD.

Disease severity
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different across disease severity groups (measured using a cumulative disease severity index) among male and female participants.

 
el-Hazmi et al42 (1994)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

Gonadotropic hormones
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly correlated with luteinizing hormone, follicle stimulating, and testosterone.

 
Grewen et al43 (2012) Pain intensity
  • Plasma cortisol among participants with SCD was positively correlated with pain intensity (measured using the visual pain analog pain scale)

Oxytocin
  • Plasma cortisol was positively correlated with oxytocin.

 
Osifo et al44 (1988)  Comparison with control groups (separate HbAA and HbAS groups)
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower in participants with SCD relative to healthy controls (HbAA).

  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different in participants with SCD relative to participants with sickle cell trait (HbAS).

Comparison with an adrenal standard
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower than the normal range (defined as 165-825 nmol/L) in 9 of 36 participants with SCD.

VOC
  • Plasma cortisol was significantly higher in participants with SCD during VOC relative to participants with SCD during routine clinic appointment.

 
Rosenbloom et al45 (1980) Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Baseline plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during steady state relative to the control group.

  • Baseline plasma cortisol was significantly lower in participants with SCD during VOC relative to the control group.

VOC
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC relative to repeated measures plasma cortisol among the same participants in steady state.

ACTH stimulation across VOC status
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC relative to participants with SCD in steady state 60 minutes after ACTH stimulation.

Insulin stimulation
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD during VOC and in steady state relative to the control group at 30 or 60 minutes after insulin stimulation.

  • Plasma cortisol was significantly lower in participants with SCD during VOC relative to the control group at 90 minutes after insulin stimulation.

  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD without VOC relative to the control group at 90 minutes after insulin stimulation.

 
Saad and Saad46 (1992)  Comparison with control group (Hb type not specified)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • ACTH-stimulated cortisol level was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group at 30, 60, and 120 minutes after stimulation.

 
Sobngwi et al47 (2018)  Comparison with control group (HbAA)
  • Basal plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

ACTH stimulation
  • Plasma cortisol was not significantly different among participants with SCD relative to the control group 60 minutes after tetracosactide stimulation.

  • The change in plasma cortisol from baseline to after tetracosactide stimulation was significantly lower among participants with SCD relative to the control group.

  • Of 10 participants with SCD, 5 (50%) did not achieve “optimal adrenal stimulation” (defined as reaching a twofold increase of basal plasma cortisol) after tetracosactide stimulation.

 

CRP, C-reactive protein; IQ, intelligence quotient; SCA, sickle cell anemia.

Included in quantitative meta-analysis.

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal